Welcome back! This is a part two so please read the first post if you haven't! If you have, read on!
So Community.... exists. I love this show, and I've wanted to talk about in some way for a very long time. I've had so many ideas for posts about this show, but honestly, how can you talk about it as a whole? This show is so wildly varied in terms of episode plots and structures, that it's covered everything.
The huge amount of variety is one of the main reasons this shown is one of my favourites. And naturally, it's had its fair share of Christmas episodes. And of the four of them, three of them are some of my favourite episodes of the show. Comparitive Religion is awesome, Regional Holiday Music is fantastic, and Intro to Knots is... not great, but is still one of the best episodes of the fourth season, which isn't saying much, but it's still pretty good.
But it's in the golden run that is the show's second season that you'll find the best Christmas episode, Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas. Abed is my favourite character in the show. His episodes are subversive and meta, but often have huge amounts of heart at the same time. Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas is both. The episode is stop motion animated. And there's actually a reason why. And that's why I recommend stopping reading this and watching this episode if you haven't. I will be spoiling this episode. I can't explain why this episode is great without spoiling it. If you haven't seen it, do it and come back. It's definitely worth your time.
So if you're still reading, you either have seen it or don't care about spoilers, so let's keep going!
In this episode, Abed wakes up one December day to find that everything is in stop motion. Or at least it is for him. Nobody else can see that the world is animated, and it's all in Abed's head. So the study group and Duncan band together to give Abed a therapy session and figure out why he's seeing this.
First of all, the animation is absolutely glorious. It's beautifully constructed , and each of the models actually look like the characters they're based on. Clay Chevy Chase in particular is pretty spot on. The design of "Planet Abed" is great too, and full of inventive imagery and fantastic designs.
The songs are great too. Community has a surprising amount of musical numbers, and all of these are pretty great. Brittabot, That's What Christmas is For and the opening theme in particular are charming, funny, and fitting of the genre that this episode is parodying. But all of them have a place within the story, and all of them are fairly funny in their own right too.
The real joy here though is how the story tells it's message. Abed's relationship with his mother really fuels the conflict, and seeing the study group rally together to comfort him is really sweet. For all the jokes they tell about Abed and his festive hallucinations, they do manage to bring it back and use it to generate some serious feels. The final musical number is perfect, not just because it's an absolute earworm and packed with funny moments, but because it brings everything full circle. Seeing the study group push their beliefs and values aside and stand up for Abed is really sweet.
Each character is fantastically represented too. Shirley is entitled and judgemental, Jeff is cynical and doesn't take the situation seriously at all, Britta always turns everything into a therapy session, Annie just wants to be supportive of Abed and help him work through his problems, Troy stands by Abed no matter what and takes it 100% seriously and Pierce just came for the cookies. John Oliver as Duncan is perfect too. He's sly, petty and is blatantly exploiting Abed and his problems. Everyone is great, and their role in the story fits with their personality perfectly.
And in the end, despite their differences, their friendship with Abed unites them. And that may sound overly sweet or obvious, but it's done in such a way that it seriously works. Once we find out that Abed is seeing this due to his mother's absence, the study group coming together to support Abed becomes something special. This is one of the big indications that these characters are becoming a family. It's heartwarming, but never unnecessarily sentimental. It's message is one that's undoubtedly festive, to stand by and support those you love.
This has to be one of my all time favourite Christmas episodes. In any show. Unique visual style and catchy soundtrack combines with strong heartwarming messages and ideas and a typically hilarious script makes Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas an absolute gem. Community is a show with many great Christmas episodes, but this episode has to be the best because I feel like it executes it's idea better than any other. It's also one of the strongest Abed-centric episodes. It really develops his character and showcases how he relates to each member of the study group. As far as this show goes, Abed's Uncontrollable Christmas is near perfect. A festive favourite for sure.