A Simple Favour is a film that I've been looking forward to for some time. I love Anna Kendrick anyway, and everything I saw about this movie just made me more hyped. A stylish mystery thriller with a comic edge about a missing woman? Sign me up. It's not the most original of premises, but lurking just beneath the surface of this movie are some fantastic twists and turns that really make it stand out. So yeah, I was really excited about this movie, and did it live up to my expectations? Let's find out!
Before I start, don't worry, I'm not going to spoil this one. It is better to go in blind, but I'll try to keep any key reveals hidden.
The plot centres on Stephanie (Anna Kendrick), a widowed vlogger who begins to develop a friendship with Emily (Blake Lively), a stylish and enigmatic woman whose son goes to the same school as Stephanie's. Right off the bat, Emily is an incredibly interesting character. She's a definite mystery, but she's got this frankness that makes her really likable. This offsets Stephanie quite well, who is more wholesome and simpler (on the surface) than Emily is. The film establishes this relationship quickly and effectively, and it's this dynamic that becomes the backbone of the plot. The chemistry between Kendrick and Lively is palpable, and it's this relationship that stays at the centre of everything, even when the movie goes batshit. The way that their arcs gradually intertwine is satisfying and fun to watch, and it leads to a truly electric atmosphere in the climax.
The plot itself is so much fun. It knows that this idea has been done to death, so there's a knowing sense of humour to the whole thing. It's never annoyingly meta, but it plays out like a lovingly crafted tribute to genre staples gone by, and it's so enjoyable as a result. Each twist it brings in warps the story, and though the film gets pretty crazy, it never becomes incoherent. As I said, the relationship between Kendrick and Lively keeps the audience tethered to the plot, and ensures that the film doesn't get lost in its own twistiness. And credit where it's due, because these twists actually feel earned. They aren't there for the sake of it, they actually make sense in the narrative. And when you combine that with the knowing sense of humour, you get a movie that's able to acknowledge it's own ridiculousness, while simultaneously taking itself seriously enough to be coherent. That's a very thin line to walk, but A Simple Favour never goes too far either way. Even when it dives into the psychological underpinnings of its characters, there's a breezy sense of fun to this movie that just works. And when the plot veers into the utterly ridiculous, it kind of knows it, and it's that self awareness that makes it sing. The climax might mean towards being too batshit for some people, but I think it works because the plot is so well structured that the film is just about able to handle all of that craziness when it does come up. It feels like a natural progression, even if it is completely bonkers.
This film is exactly what I needed it to be. It's fun, it's gorgeous to look at and it's intricately plotted with just the right amount of craziness to justify those twists. Yeah, it loses some of that structure in the home stretch, and starts to run in pure madness, but it manages to bring that around to a ln ending that's coherent enough to satisfy. The performances here are electric. Lively and Kendrick have one of the best dynamics I've seen all year, and it's this that fuels the movie. There's so much to their relationship, and unpacking it becomes the fun part. This is done so well that it's actually worth the price of admission in itself. Even when Lively isn't on screen, you feel her presence, and it's her essence that haunts the movie like a high society ghost. It's an interesting edge that undercuts all of the glossy fun, and Paul Feige is skilled enough to balance these aspects, and the result is awesome.