Good Boys is an odd premise on paper. Basically, take all of the wild and raucous antics of Superbad, but have the characters be twelve year old boys. The result is a film that, as pretty hilariously invoked in the trailer, its own leads can't actually see. And yeah, the trailers for this were pretty good, setting it up as kind of like a live action South Park. Actually seeing Good Boys, it's definitely not a bad film, but it's also really not as good as it could have been. The plot basically follows three kids who lose a drone when spying on a neighbour, and spend a whole day trying to get it back, all the while encountering some crazy, wildly inappropriate things. This is an idea that lends itself to funny situations, even if the actual plot itself is pretty thin, but the jokes are well spread here, and the ones that work definitely get laughs.
I guess one problem I have with the jokes is that, well, they all revolve around one specific idea; these kids doing things they're not supposed to because they don't know any better. That's not to say that that's not funny, but after a while, it'd be nice to have some sort of variety. I didn't have as much of an issue with it as some critics had, but it's still something that holds the film back from being as funny as it could have been. And also, because it's a modern, mainstream comedy, the vast majority of the jokes are in the trailer. So when these things do happen, their impact is hugely lessened and they're much less funny. I didn't really laugh when these things happened, and the stuff I really found funny wasn't in the trailer at all. Don't get me wrong, there are jokes that really work ( Stephen Merchant's cameo and a hilariously angsty walk home were definitely the highlights), and there are some incredibly funny lines here, but the jokes are hit and miss, and the ratio is pretty even, so for every genuinely funny gag, there's another that winds up dead on arrival
Not that you can fault the cast for that. The three young actors here are actually great. Jacob Tremblay gets a chance to exercise his comic chops, and again proves why he's one of the most exciting young talents at the minute. He actually proves to be a pretty funny performer, nailing the balance between brashness and innocence that stops the premise of the film from completely falling flat. Brady Noon is also pretty awesome here, not just hilarious but also really able to convey his character's (surprisingly well written) arc, where he has to make a choice between fitting in or following his passion for singing. But Keith L Williams is undoubtedly the standout here. Every line he says is absolutely hysterical, and the way his character's (often incredibly inconvenient) honesty is used is really, really funny and fuels some of the film's best jokes. The film is definitely hit and miss with both its comedy and its quality, but the three leads are consistently awesome, and surprisingly believable. The film would have fallen flat incredibly quickly if you didn't believe in these characters, but you actually do, and for all of its stumbles, this is one thing that it does really well
Speaking of stumbles though, there is one thing here that really bothered me in the third act, and that's the constant attempts to be heartwarming. Look, I get what they were going for, and it just didn't work. It felt so forced, and even though the cast were undoubtedly committed, I just found it so hard to care what was going on. I guess it's because the heartfelt conclusion feels too small scale here. I'm not asking for something overly profound, but the actual resolution feels kind of inconsequential, and so it's really hard to feel anything, especially because it happens so late in the film. The first two acts largely focus on the comedy, so when it tries to be sweet, it's too late for anything to actually resonate, and although I definitely appreciate what they were going for, I don't think it worked half as well as it should have. The sentiment is definitely nice, almost going for a similar thing to Stand By Me, but very unlike that film, the plot was too basic and rooted in comedy for that kind of idea to work.
That's an issue that only really affects to home stretch, because everything else is actually really entertaining for the most part. The film never drags or outstays its welcome, and even if the jokes don't always hit, they're never bad enough to derail the film altogether. It's actually a decently fun time, one that was obviously made with a lot of enthusiasm, and when it's funny, it's really freaking funny, with the hits registering a lot more than the misses, which definitely compensates for their slight infrequency. Despite the content, it's actually harmless fun, a movie that doesn't achieve everything it sets out to do, but does the things it does well enough to prevent that from really being much of an issue. True, the stumbles are hard to ignore, but the things Good Boys is good at are definitely worth the price of admission, because although they don't quite outweigh the problems, they do make it a really fun time. It's unbalanced, but when it's fun, it is quite fun