First impressions are hard. Take the first episode of a show for instance. You want it to be good enough to convince you that the show is worth watching but not so good that it seems like the show can't live up to its opener. You want to be introduced to the world and the characters while also being assured that there's space for them to grow and develop past the first season. It's amazing how easy this is to get wrong, but a great pilot is something truly special, and an art unto itself. There's no real criteria for what makes a great first episode outside of their ability to sell a show and give the viewer an idea of what they're in for from a single installment. Narrowing it down to ten episodes that I think do this well was tough, but here's a list of the ten pilots that drew me in from the start and made me hungry for more. Obviously, this is all my opinion and entirely relative to shows I've seen. If something isn't on this list, it could be because I haven't seen the show, or because it just didn't impress me as much as the stuff that made the cut. I should also say that this list is judging these episodes in isolation, and doesn't reflect how I feel about the shows as a whole. Also because we're only talking about first episodes here, it's safe to say there aren't going to be many spoilers on this list. With that out of the way, let's get into it
10. The Beginning (Samurai Jack)
I was in two minds about how to count Samurai Jack's first episode for this list because, in the middle of the series' run, the first three episode were rereleased as a standalone TV movie, but in the end I decided to just take the first chapter on its own. It says a lot about how great of a storyteller Gennedy Tartakovsky is that in 22 short minutes he perfectly establishes a huge threat that goes on to loom over the whole show and cover the entire backstory of the only hero who can conquer it. Jack's origin is compacted into a montage that is comprehensive and economic without feeling like a series of flashcards conveying the most basic pieces of information. This was always a show more focused on the journey, establishing a problem early on and spending five seasons trying to solve it, so condensing everything before Jack's arrival in the future into a single sequence actually ends up being an incredible decision from a storytelling perspective
We learn so much about Jack through seeing his training and education. Samurai Jack is a show that always prioritised visual storytelling over an abundance of dialogue so being able to set so much up with a few choice images is a testament to how well the show is able to convey its plot. It's an episode that provides both a catalyst to the series' conflict and an introduction to its truly singular style, and it perfectly sets up the massive journey to come
9. It's Summer and We're Running Out of Ice (Watchmen)
From the first scene depicting the actual Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921, it was clear that Watchmen was a show with a lot to say. Damon Lindelof's take on Alan Moore's masterful graphic novel was never a straight adaptation, and sought to find an original way to use the story to examine contemporary America from the start. The show immediately sets up in universe events like the White Night while also making it clear that Watchmen is a show that is keen to dissect the venomous ills that have infected America for centuries. Through doing this it sets up a believable, real conflict, using vigilantes to dissect ideas of justice and the law and ask who is fit to uphold it
Aesthetically it's a fascinating beast, too. The show remixes classic motifs and images from the graphic novel while also splicing in ideas from pop culture, in particular using 1955's Oklahoma! to set up a particularly crucial plot beat. It's an engrossing introduction that sets up a clear, coherent plot before promising that the show to come will do everything in its power to complicate it and warp it into something really special. It drew scorn from a certain portion of the fanbase who complained that it was "too political", but that just goes to show that they weren't paying attention. The comic was always an explicit social comment, and with It's Summer and We're Running Out of Ice, the show immediately lets the audience know that it's about to follow suit
8. Episode 1 (Fleabag)
I think one thing that makes a great pilot is the ability to get in and get out, establishing everything about the show in a relatively short period of time. Fleabag's first episode moves with all the speed and chaos of a whirlwind, introducing the main character and Phoebe Waller-Bridge's style of to-camera addresses to establish Fleabag's perspective perfectly. There's a really natural flow through which the show introduces all of the central players, and even some less central side characters, hilariously dubbed Bus Rodent and Arsehole Guy. The show is pacey from the start, and promises to keep that up throughout its run. When Fleabag looks down the barrel of the camera after a hectic half hour, she's letting you know that, whatever mess she finds herself in next, you're along for the ride
It's also bitingly funny and perfectly introduces the show's trademark blend of caustic quips and genuine heartbreak. When it lets you go at the end after a frenetic and relentless 30 minutes, it ensures that your interest is piqued and you're thirsty for more. Fleabag had been heavily praised for so many things but I don't think enough attention is given to how perfect of an introduction we get to the titular character. You know who she is within the first ten minutes, and after twenty more you're rooting for her while simultaneously cringing at every decision she makes. You want her to succeed, and nailing such a specific, chaotic tone in the first episode is exactly what makes Fleabag such a special piece of television
7. Offred (The Handmaid's Tale)
Speculative fiction can be tricky, but right from the start The Handmaid's Tale excelled at immersing its audience in a world that, for all of its differences, contained some fundamental similarities to the contemporary landscape it was released in. From its opening minutes, it's clear that this is something really special. It's a hard story to tell but from the first episode, it ensures that you're aware of how the show is going to approach such difficult, contentious subject matter. Offred is an honest, direct hour of television that warns the audience that the road ahead isn't going to be easy, but urges them to keep going because this story matters. The episode introduces Gilead as a sort of nightmarish fusion of real world terror, full of misogyny, homophobia, sectarianism and sexual violence. It's by no means easy viewing, but it's a perfect articulation of the worst pains that society has to offer
Crucially, the episode ends with an act of private, defiant hope. Offred is a character you become attached to straight away, and Elizabeth Moss excels at making you believe in this character and ensures that you feel her plight every step of the way. The Handmaid's Tale's first episode is a breathless, brutal piece of television that demands that you stick with it, and it's so impressive that the writers managed to nail a tone this tricky as quickly as they did. I have my qualms with where the series goes after the first season but I can't deny that the pilot is extraordinary and essential, putting so many modern furies and anxieties onscreen with elegance and honesty
6. Pilot (Community)
Community's main cast isn't big (seven key players for the first part of season one), but they're all huge personalities with so much going on, and introducing all of them in one go while also summing up where they're starting from and how they'll come to change was never going to be easy. For that reason alone, Community's pilot is a work of genius, giving the viewer the best introduction to this group of characters whose relationships become progressively intricate and entrenched in the show's twisty meta-humour. The episode brings you in during a key moment that all of them are going through; as different as the Greendale seven are, they've all made the same decision to enroll in community college and have all found themselves together, ready to embark on all sorts of antics
There are so many character moments in this episode that go on to feel so on brand for these characters. The first scene where the study group is together is such a perfect communication of who they all are as we meet them, perfectly setting them up for six seasons of change and development. It also immediately introduces the two biggest themes of Community: that connecting and engaging with people different to you is massively beneficial and also the idea that people aren't defined by their past and it's never too late to change. The fact that the show got all of this in from the first chapter is nothing short of stunning, and the fact that it's hilarious is the cherry on top
5. Boardwalk Empire (Boardwalk Empire)
Something I noticed when putting this list together is that so many great pilots come from period pieces. Seriously, four of the next five episodes are set in the past, and I think part of what makes them so great is how much harder they have to work to establish their setting and make the viewer believe that they're there. When this is done well, it's a really special thing, and Boardwalk Empire seamlessly submerges you into the sea of indulgence and amorality that is 1920s Atlantic City. Of course it probably doesn't hurt that the episode is directed by Martin Scorsese, but that's only part of what makes Boardwalk Empire such a great introduction to.... well, Boardwalk Empire
We meet Nucky Thompson in the middle of a deal, which is how we'll come to see him again and again. The way Nucky bends not just the truth but every one of his personal values to get what he wants is so crucial to his character, and by meeting him as he's doing this, we're instantly aware that this is his bread and butter, his natural way of operating. This meeting is also significant because it marks the moment his path crosses with Margaret Schroeder, and because their relationship is so central to the show, kicking it off early is key to making Boardwalk work right from the start. The pilot also introduces the viewer to the way the show flirts with history; the moment we meet Al Capone is the exact point that the show lays out its MO. When the episode wraps up, it really feels like the start of something huge, the moment that this well-oiled operation is suddenly on the verge of breaking down completely
4. Smoke Gets in Your Eyes (Mad Men)
Mad Men is such a slow-burning pressure cooker of a show that, looking back on its pilot, ends in a totally different place than it began. Maybe that's obvious, because the show is about the gradual change of one era into another and Don Draper's steady decline in the process, but watching Smoke Gets in Your Eyes again, it almost feels like a trick being played on the audience. It perfectly reconstructs 1960 New York and promises you that you're watching a period piece about a successful but empty man. That's mostly true, but the genius of this episode lies in the fact that it's just the first step on a descending staircase through changing fashions and attitudes, and it's clear from minute one that there's something really powerful to be found on every subsequent step
I suppose what I'm trying to say is that Smoke Gets in Your Eyes is such a perfect evocation of one specific moment in time that it's easy to forget that everything you see is fluid and on the brink of change. Don Draper's world isn't permanent- a fact he doesn't realise- and by setting the tone early on in such a perfect, controlled way, the show is establishing a clear point for the beginning of Don's downfall. But the real brilliance of the episode is its ending. After seeing Don Draper as a cool, confident man about town, we meet his family, and the show's real conflict begins. 14 years later, Smoke Gets in Your Eyes is still a blistering 50 minutes of television
3. The Sopranos (The Sopranos)
The Sopranos sets itself apart from the bulk of mob dramas in two ways. The first is its sense of humour, openly laughing at the absurdity of these characters from the first episode, but the second and most important thing the show does is look at Tony through the lens of his anxiety and the therapy he attends as a result. One of the first things we know about him is that he's recently suffered a serious panic attack, and in doing that, the show immediately establishes the intimacy with which we're going to view him. Tony's complexity and vulnerability are key to his character, and from his first session with Dr. Melfi, it's clear that he's not some cold, stoic stereotype. We see his rocky relationship with his mother and the volatility of Junior and Christopher, and the show is quick to frame these characters not just as people in Tony's life but as potential triggers to his constant internal panic. Within an hour, the show already feels distinct and fully formed, effortlessly introducing all of its key concepts
It's just the perfect way to kick off such a big, dynamic show like this. As the audience, we have the ability to see Tony on a level that nobody else in his life- including himself- can. The pilot sets it up so well, placing us in a similar position to Melfi where we're left to observe him and glean meaning from his interactions with the people in his life. It was never a straightforward mafia show and David Chase makes that clear from minute one. It's also the episode that introduced the world to Steve Van Zandt's Silvio Dante, and it's fair to say that we as a species will always be in the show's debt because of that
2. Method and Madness (The Knick)
If you haven't seen Jack Amiel, Michael Begler and Steven Soderbergh's beautiful, criminally underrated The Knick, then you're really missing out. The show perfectly captures the turbulence of the medical world as well as issues of race in America in a way that feels eerily applicable to the present day. Method and Madness is a great intro, not just to the uneasy world of The Knick but to the drug-fueled hellscape that is the inside of John Thackery's head. Watching him stumble from opium den to operating theatre serves as a note perfect introduction to such a difficult character, and his desperate response to withdrawl at the episode's end is a fascinating way for the show to approach the life of an addict
But the heart of this episode, and indeed the show as a whole, is André Holland's Algernon Edwards. The Knick's portrayal of the horrifying prejudice Edwards faces in his field is instantly hard-hitting, and the show wastes no time in getting into the issues that plague America, not just in 1900, but in 2014 and still in 2021. It's another period show with a perfect introduction, and makes its setting a mirror to the present better than possibly any other show on this list, the pilot above it included. If you need a reason to check out The Knick before its upcoming third season (helmed by Barry Jenkins no less), then look no further than Method and Madness, a wonderful, hard-hitting intro to an utterly singular show
1. The Vanishing of Will Byers (Stranger Things)
Because it's such a phenomenon, it's easy to forget just how small-scale Stranger Things' initial mystery is. Before every season felt like a cultural event and people were throwing around Barb memes like they were going out of fashion, The Vanishing of Will Byers transported its audience to a chilly Autumn evening in 1983, where the sleepy town of Hawkins, Indiana was about to be forever changed by both a disappearance and a new arrival. It'd be slightly disrespectful to how great the rest of Stranger Things debut season is to suggest that this episode would work better as an hour long thriller about a missing child and the effect on a small town, but in retrospect, the show aces this aspect of its story so well that if Eleven, the Upside Down and the rest of the supernatural thrills were never introduced, the show would still have a deeply effective central mystery
The supernatural stuff is incredibly done but what makes this first episode work is how well it nails each of its introductions. It's not interested in only using its first episode as a catalyst to cosmic-horror hijinks, and takes the time to set the scene in a way that feels so honest and true. The opening D and D game and the first appearance of Jim Hopper are moments that resonate way beyond any horror-tinged mystery the show will go on to lay down. It's a key ingredient that's missing from so many supernatural shows and even from later seasons of Stranger Things: a genuine connection with its time and place. It's often been described as a show of nostalgic delights but the Duffer brothers believe in their setting so much that it stops becoming purely aesthetical and begins to feel alive and changed by the events of the story. Without this, the most crucial piece of its foundation, the show would never have worked quite as well as it does
And then there's the mystery. The Vanishing of Will Byers excels at making you care, at urging you to keep watching to find out what happens. Because the setting is so believable and the characters are so likeable, you want to spend more time piecing together whatever's going to come next. It has the crucial ingredient that a pilot needs: the ability to instill curiosity in the viewer with the promise of a larger payoff. Taken as a whole, three-season package, I don't necessarily think Stranger Things is the best show on this list, but in terms of its first chapter, it's hard for me to think of a better way to start a show than The Vanishing of Will Byers